Education Minister Pradhan Deems UGC and NCERT Textbook Controversies 'Avoidable'
Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan has publicly addressed the recent controversies surrounding the UGC equity guidelines and an NCERT textbook chapter on judicial corruption, labeling both situations as "avoidable." Speaking at the Times Now Summit on Friday, Pradhan acknowledged the public discourse but stressed the government's constitutional duty to prevent discrimination.
UGC Guidelines Under Supreme Court Scrutiny
"I accept that they (controversies) were avoidable, especially the way they were presented," Pradhan stated. Regarding the UGC matter, he noted it is currently sub judice and under the Supreme Court's cognizance, limiting his public comments. "The discussion in society on the UGC matter is sub judice and under the Supreme Court’s cognizance, so I cannot comment publicly. But I would like to assure citizens that we do not endorse victimization against anyone," he emphasized.
The UGC guidelines, issued in January with the aim of curbing discrimination against SC, ST, and OBC students, mandated equal opportunity cells, 24/7 helplines, and strict complaint redressal timelines. However, they triggered protests from some quarters, including within the ruling BJP, which claimed the norms were discriminatory. The Supreme Court later granted an interim stay, observing that they appeared prima facie "vague" and could be misused, leading to calls for redrafting.
Pradhan added, "This (UGC matter) is under the court’s cognizance; as the court frames it, the government will implement the system in line with the Constitution." He stressed that the government has a constitutional responsibility to ensure that no form of discrimination occurs.
NCERT Textbook Chapter on Judicial Corruption
On the NCERT issue, Pradhan noted that the Supreme Court has provided guidance. "It has been said that a well-monitored chapter will be added under its supervision, and we are engaged in that work," he explained. A committee has been formed under the leadership of Justice Indu Malhotra, and the court had also asked for the inclusion of Bhopal Law Academy.
"All this work is ongoing, and the chapter is being prepared. It will be placed before the court and added accordingly," Pradhan stated. Earlier this month, the NCERT issued a public apology for including a chapter on judicial corruption in a Class 8 social science textbook, which had drawn criticism from the Supreme Court. The textbook stated that corruption, a massive backlog of cases, and a shortage of judges are among the challenges faced by the judicial system.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi had expressed unhappiness over the chapter and asked for "accountability to be fixed." The NCERT announced that the entire textbook would be withdrawn as part of the response to the controversy.
Government's Commitment to Education and Justice
Pradhan's comments highlight the government's efforts to balance educational reforms with legal and societal expectations. He reiterated the administration's commitment to upholding constitutional values while navigating complex issues in the education sector. The controversies have sparked widespread debate, underscoring the sensitive nature of policy implementation in India's diverse educational landscape.
As these matters progress through judicial and administrative channels, the government aims to ensure transparency and fairness, aligning with both court directives and public sentiment. The ongoing developments will likely shape future policies on equity and curriculum design in Indian education.
