Hrithik Roshan Champions Filmmakers' Vision Amid Ramayana VFX Debate
The recently released teaser for Nitesh Tiwari's highly anticipated mythological epic Ramayana, starring Ranbir Kapoor, has ignited a polarized reaction across social media platforms. While many fans have praised the casting and scale, a significant segment of online commentators has criticized the visual effects, labeling them as "video game-like" and questioning their quality. This ongoing digital debate has now drawn a thoughtful intervention from Bollywood superstar Hrithik Roshan, who has publicly come to the defense of filmmakers, advocating for a more nuanced and aware perspective when evaluating visual effects in cinema.
"Bad VFX Exists... But So Does Vision": Hrithik's Instagram Defense
Taking to his official Instagram account, Hrithik Roshan penned a detailed post acknowledging the existence of subpar visual effects while passionately arguing for the recognition of artistic intent and cinematic ambition. "Yes bad VFX exists. It's sometimes so bad it's painful to watch. Especially for me... and especially when it's a film I'm part of," the actor candidly admitted, reflecting a personal understanding of the craft's challenges.
However, he swiftly pivoted to celebrate the pioneering spirit of contemporary Indian filmmakers. "Today some special humans among us, like the makers of films like Kalki, Baahubali, Ramayana... are my heroes. They have the guts and vision to do what's never been done—all for the love of cinema," Hrithik wrote. He drew inspiration from his own childhood, citing films like Back to the Future as foundational influences, and emphasized the noble purpose behind undertaking such visually ambitious projects. "To me that's noble. The intention by itself deserves applause! I am proud of my fellow Indians. What I would give to be a part of such dreams even as an assistant," he shared, underscoring his deep respect for the filmmaking process.
Different VFX Styles: A Matter of Artistic Choice, Not Quality
Directly addressing the specific criticism surrounding the Ramayana teaser, Hrithik Roshan provided an educational perspective on visual effects styles. He explained that not all VFX is designed to achieve photorealism; instead, different stylistic approaches are employed to realize a director's unique vision. "In my little understanding... there are different VFX styles adopted by makers to bring their vision to life," he noted, adding, "You can like one style over the other but neither is wrong." He compared this diversity to the varied styles found in animation and broader cinematic choices across different films.
The actor then offered his definition of what truly constitutes poor visual effects, distinguishing it from mere stylistic preference. "Bad VFX is if the movie promises ‘photorealism’ but is unable to inhabit it fully... Or the promise is of storybook style but they fail in making it beautiful enough," Hrithik clarified. He stressed that criticizing a deliberately stylized, non-photorealistic approach for not looking real is fundamentally unfair, as "it's not meant to be."
A Call for More Informed Audience Criticism
Hrithik Roshan concluded his extensive note with a powerful appeal to moviegoers and critics alike to refine their approach to evaluating films. He suggested that sometimes, what is hastily dismissed as "bad VFX" might simply be an unexpected artistic style. "So sometimes when you say ‘bad VFX.’ Maybe it’s just a style you didn’t expect?" he posed rhetorically.
His final recommendation was for audiences to engage in more thoughtful critique. "So next time don’t just ask, ‘Is it real?’ First ask, ‘Is it right for the story?’... Debate it. But debate it with awareness," Hrithik urged, advocating for a shift from superficial judgment to a deeper appreciation of narrative and directorial intent.
Ramayana: A Star-Studded Epic Awaits
Directed by acclaimed filmmaker Nitesh Tiwari, Ramayana is one of the most ambitious Indian cinematic projects currently in production. The film features a stellar ensemble cast with Ranbir Kapoor portraying Lord Ram, Sai Pallavi as Sita, Yash in the role of Ravana, Ravie Dubey as Lakshman, and Sunny Deol embodying the character of Hanuman. Slated for a grand theatrical release during the Diwali festival this year, Ramayana: Part I promises to be a landmark visual spectacle, aiming to bring the ancient epic to life with modern filmmaking technology and a fresh creative vision.
