The release of Stranger Things Season 5, Volume 2 has sparked a fiery debate online, with a pivotal moment involving Noah Schnapp's character, Will Byers, at the center of the storm. While many fans celebrated the emotional culmination of Will's long-simmering personal journey, others questioned its timing and narrative integration, leading to a divided fandom.
Adin Ross Questions The Scene's Placement and Logic
Popular streamer Adin Ross has become a prominent voice among critics. In a viral clip from his stream, dated December 29, 2025, Ross took issue with Will's coming-out scene, despite admitting he hadn't watched the full episode. His core criticism focused on the scene's placement late in the season, as the characters face the apocalyptic threat of Vecna.
Ross mockingly questioned the storytelling logic, suggesting the scene was framed as a key to defeating the villain. "But you're telling me right now he has an intervention, tells everyone that he's gay, and that's how he beats the monster?" he said, labeling it "the definition of Hollywood goyslop." He clarified he had no issue with the character's sexuality or Schnapp being gay in real life, but argued the moment felt emotionally disconnected from the primary conflict.
Creators and Star Defend The Long-Planned Character Arc
The show's creators, The Duffer Brothers, have consistently defended this narrative choice. In interviews with outlets like Capital FM and PEOPLE, they explained that Will's arc, including this moment, was mapped out years in advance and was never intended as a mere plot device.
They emphasized its significance as a pivotal point in the character's evolution, a sentiment echoed by actor Noah Schnapp. Schnapp revealed he was deeply moved when he first read the scene, underscoring its emotional weight for the character he has portrayed since the show's inception.
A Clash of Perspectives on Storytelling
This controversy highlights a classic clash in storytelling perspectives. For Ross and some viewers, every major beat in the final season must directly service the central, action-driven plot against Vecna. For the creators, resolving long-standing character arcs is equally crucial to delivering a satisfying conclusion to the beloved series.
The debate continues to rage on social media platforms like X, where the clip of Ross's comments circulates widely. As fans digest Volume 2, the discussion now pivots to how these character resolutions will tie into the ultimate finale, scheduled for release on New Year's Eve 2025.
All episodes of Stranger Things Season 5, Volume 1 and 2, are currently available for streaming on Netflix.
