In a stunning move that has sent shockwaves through Bachelor Nation, the franchise has announced its next leading lady. Taylor Frankie Paul, the breakout star from 'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives', will be the Bachelorette for the upcoming Season 22. This unexpected choice marks a significant departure from the show's traditional casting pool, leaving fans and former contestants alike utterly surprised.
Kelsey Anderson's Candid Reaction to the News
The news landed with a splash, and even recent fan-favourite Kelsey Anderson, who got engaged to Joey Graziadei on Season 28 of 'The Bachelor', was caught off guard. Anderson revealed her initial shock in an interview with StyleCaster back in January. She confessed she was "utterly surprised" by the announcement, having believed that 'The Bachelorette' wasn't returning this season. "I thought that they were only gonna do 'The Bachelor'. That's what I heard," Anderson stated.
Her reaction mirrored the collective disbelief buzzing online. After a string of standard 'Bachelor' seasons, a left-field choice like Paul, who comes from outside the usual franchise circle, was the last thing anyone anticipated. Anderson recalled hearing the speculation the night before the official reveal, noting, "somebody the night before was like, 'oh, did you hear, it looks like Taylor Frankie Paul might be the bachelorette.'" Clearly, she wasn't the only one taken aback.
From Surprise to Wholehearted Support
However, Kelsey Anderson's initial shock quickly transformed into genuine excitement and support. A longtime fan of Taylor Frankie Paul, Anderson praised her sense of humor and openness online. Once the news settled, her perspective shifted entirely. "To me it is, I'm excited!" she declared enthusiastically. "I love Mormon Wives! I love Taylor, she's always been so kind to me."
Anderson's support goes beyond mere polite words. She expressed a sincere willingness to guide Paul through the unique experience, offering, "I'm excited to support her on her journey and whatever she needs." This authentic, supportive energy resonated deeply with fans, who appreciated that she was genuinely rooting for Taylor to find her happy ending.
In a charming behind-the-scenes glimpse, Anderson also shared a lighthearted moment with her fiancé, Joey Graziadei. While she was reeling from the news, Joey remained decidedly chill, a reaction that made Kelsey laugh. It was a simple reminder that these reality stars experience everyday moments just like anyone else.
What This Means for The Bachelorette's Future
With 'The Bachelorette' set to make its return in March 2026, Kelsey Anderson's blend of surprise, admiration, and encouragement has only fueled the growing hype. Her reaction perfectly encapsulates the fanbase's current mood: Taylor Frankie Paul's season is poised to be anything but ordinary. This bold casting decision has successfully ignited conversations and anticipation in the best way possible.
By stepping outside its established ecosystem, the franchise is signaling a fresh direction. If the reactions from Kelsey Anderson and the wider Bachelor Nation are any indication, Season 22 is shaping up to be a chapter that nobody wants to miss. The stage is now set for Taylor Frankie Paul to embark on a unique journey for love, with the support of former stars and an intrigued audience eagerly waiting to watch.
