Sudharsan's Failure Puts Gill in Spotlight
Young batsman Sai Sudharsan's disappointing performance in the ongoing second Test against South Africa has unexpectedly dragged his Gujarat Titans captain Shubman Gill into controversy. The left-handed batter managed just 15 runs off 40 balls in India's first innings at Guwahati's Barsapara Cricket Stadium on Monday, November 24, 2025.
Fan Backlash and Selection Questions
With South Africa posting a massive 489 runs in their first innings, much was expected from Sudharsan batting at the crucial number three position. However, his dismissal - brilliantly caught by Ryan Rickelton at mid-wicket - triggered widespread criticism from fans on social media platforms.
Many supporters expressed their frustration, suggesting that Sudharsan's place in the Test team might be influenced by his connection with Gill. "He's getting so many chances because he's Gill's friend, while other players are dropped after just one or two matches," wrote one angry fan on X.
Another user questioned the selection criteria, stating, "Sai wasn't even selected based on his domestic performance, he was selected for Tests based on his IPL performance."
The Gujarat Titans Connection
The controversy stems from both players representing Gujarat Titans in the Indian Premier League, where they form a formidable opening partnership. While Gill captains the franchise, Sudharsan has been his regular opening partner in the cash-rich T20 tournament.
This connection has led to what fans are calling the 'GT Captain Quota' theory, suggesting that personal relationships within the IPL franchise might be influencing national team selections. The debate has gained significant traction among cricket enthusiasts who are closely following the Test match.
The timing of this controversy is particularly sensitive as India seeks to build a strong response to South Africa's substantial first innings total. The team management now faces increased scrutiny over their selection decisions as the match progresses.
