The Wrestling Federation of India (WFI) has moved the Supreme Court challenging the Delhi High Court order that permitted wrestler Vinesh Phogat to take part in the Asian Games selection trials. The development comes after Phogat faced disqualification from the Paris Olympics due to being overweight ahead of her gold medal bout, an incident that the WFI claimed caused 'national embarrassment'.
Background of the Case
Vinesh Phogat, one of India's most decorated wrestlers, was disqualified from the Paris Olympics after failing the weigh-in before the gold medal match. The Wrestling Federation of India had earlier issued a notice to Phogat, accusing her of bringing disrepute to the nation. In response, Phogat approached the Delhi High Court, which on 27 May 2026 allowed her to participate in the Asian Games trials, citing principles of natural justice and her right to a fair hearing.
WFI's Argument in Supreme Court
The WFI, in its petition filed before the Supreme Court, argued that the Delhi High Court's order was 'erroneous and against the established disciplinary framework' of the federation. The federation contended that allowing Phogat to compete without facing consequences for the Paris Olympics incident would set a wrong precedent and undermine the authority of sports governing bodies. It further stated that the notice issued to Phogat was not punitive but a procedural step to maintain discipline among athletes representing the nation.
Delhi High Court's Reasoning
The Delhi High Court, in its order, had observed that Phogat's disqualification from the Olympics was a result of a technical rule violation and did not involve any intentional wrongdoing. The court emphasized that athletes should not be deprived of opportunities to represent the country in future events without a proper inquiry. It directed the WFI to include Phogat in the Asian Games trials, ensuring that her career is not unfairly impacted.
Next Steps
The Supreme Court is expected to hear the WFI's plea later this week. Meanwhile, the Asian Games trials are scheduled to commence in June 2026, and the outcome of the legal battle will determine whether Vinesh Phogat can compete. The case has drawn significant attention from the sports fraternity, with many debating the balance between disciplinary action and an athlete's right to compete.
Phogat, who has won multiple medals for India including at the Commonwealth Games and Asian Games, remains hopeful of a favorable ruling. Her legal team has argued that the WFI's notice was arbitrary and violated her fundamental rights. The Supreme Court's decision will have far-reaching implications for athlete governance in India.
