The Pittsburgh Steelers are widely expected to see quarterback Aaron Rodgers retire after the 2026 season, creating a significant void under center. While the team currently has Drew Allar, Will Howard, and Mason Rudolph as potential successors, questions linger about their ability to lead the franchise long-term. NFL analyst Mike Florio has a clear alternative: Baker Mayfield.
What Did Mike Florio Say About Baker Mayfield and the Steelers?
Florio did not mince words during a recent segment, stating: "Baker Mayfield would be perfect in Pittsburgh. He would be perfect. I know they would like to get off this train of older veteran quarterbacks, but he's a spring chicken compared to Aaron Rodgers. I would make a beeline for Baker Mayfield. If I'm Mike McCarthy and the Steelers and I get through this season with options like Drew Allar, Will Howard, and Mason Rudolph, I am doing whatever it takes to get Baker Mayfield in Pittsburgh."
This endorsement carries weight. Mayfield is significantly younger than Rodgers and has demonstrated the ability to reset his career after being counted out. His resurgence with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers stands as one of the most compelling quarterback stories in recent years. The Steelers, historically drawn to experienced and resilient signal-callers, could view Mayfield as a natural fit.
Is Baker Mayfield Actually Available, and What Would It Cost Pittsburgh?
Mayfield is entering the final year of his contract with the Buccaneers in 2026. Extension talks have publicly stalled, and Mayfield has indicated that if no deal is reached before the season begins, negotiations will be postponed until after the year ends. This stance suggests he is not committed to staying in Tampa and recognizes his market value.
Mayfield originally signed a three-year, $100 million deal with the Buccaneers after revitalizing his career. However, the quarterback market has shifted, with reports indicating he will seek at least $50 million per season if he hits free agency in 2027. For Pittsburgh, this represents a substantial financial commitment, especially as they look to rebuild around a new offensive identity.
Still, if the Steelers finish the 2026 season without a clear answer at quarterback, the situation could change rapidly. Pittsburgh has historically been willing to spend when the right player is available. If Rodgers retires and none of Allar, Howard, or Rudolph emerges as a legitimate starter, the organization will urgently explore options.
For now, the connection between Mayfield and Pittsburgh remains speculative. Many variables must align before this becomes a concrete possibility. However, the logic behind Florio's suggestion is sound: the Steelers need a quarterback, and Mayfield could be on the market. Sometimes the most obvious solutions become reality.
