The History of Sound Movie Review: A Thin Romance That Lacks Depth
The History of Sound, directed by Oliver Hermanus and adapted by Ben Shattuck from his own short stories, presents a visually stunning but emotionally hollow romance. Starring Paul Mescal and Josh O'Connor, the film struggles to move beyond superficial beauty, earning a disappointing 2 out of 5 stars.
Beautiful Scenery, Shallow Story
Set against the pristine American wilderness during World War I, the film follows Lionel (Mescal) and David (O'Connor) as they embark on a journey to collect folk songs across Maine. Despite the picturesque backdrop and the undeniable chemistry between the two leads, the narrative feels thin and underdeveloped. The movie, often dubbed "Piggyback Mountain," proves that not every tale of love between two handsome men in nature becomes a masterpiece.
Lack of Conflict and Character Depth
The film's most significant flaw is its avoidance of meaningful conflict. Lionel and David face no real obstacles—not family disapproval, societal prejudice as gay men in 1917-1920 America, or the turmoil of World War I. Even Lionel's harsh farm life in Kentucky fails to disrupt the story's languid pace. David's background remains largely unexplored, leaving both characters feeling one-dimensional.
Mescal and O'Connor are given little to do but exchange loving glances, with occasional respites where they interact with others. Lionel's mumbled dialogue about not worrying and David's fleeting hints at prejudice do little to add depth to their relationship.
Moments of Promise Overshadowed by Monologues
The film shines brightest when Lionel and David are together, particularly during their folk song collection project. These scenes capture a sense of warmth and connection, with isolated families they meet offering glimpses of more compelling stories. However, these moments are often undermined by unnecessary monologues.
At one point, the film introduces a sense of genuine loss, only to sacrifice it for yet another speech. As Lionel notes, folk songs are "the most warm-blooded music," but the movie itself lacks the warmth and vitality needed to make their romance resonate.
Final Verdict
The History of Sound boasts strong performances from Mescal and O'Connor and beautiful cinematography, but it fails to deliver a compelling narrative. With a runtime that feels stretched thin and a story that avoids conflict, the film ultimately falls short of its potential. For fans of the actors or period dramas, it might offer visual appeal, but those seeking emotional depth will likely be left wanting.
Director: Oliver Hermanus
Cast: Paul Mescal, Josh O'Connor, Chris Cooper
Rating: 2 stars
