As temperatures continue to rise in New Delhi, the Supreme Court on Wednesday urged lawyers to opt for virtual hearings to avoid the scorching heat. While declining to issue any judicial directions mandating online appearances, the court strongly recommended that legal practitioners make use of the online mode wherever possible to ensure their well-being and comfort.
Court's Advisory Amid Heatwave
The bench, comprising Justices S. K. Kaul and A. S. Bopanna, noted that the extreme weather conditions could pose health risks. The court emphasized that the existing infrastructure for virtual hearings is robust and can be effectively utilized. It further stated that the decision to appear virtually or physically rests with the lawyers, but encouraged them to choose the online option when feasible.
Background
This advisory comes in the wake of a severe heatwave gripping the national capital, with temperatures crossing 45 degrees Celsius. Several government offices and schools have already adopted work-from-home and online classes to mitigate the impact. The Supreme Court's suggestion aligns with these measures, aiming to reduce unnecessary travel and exposure to the heat.
Reactions from the Legal Community
Senior advocates welcomed the court's pragmatic approach. Advocate Prashant Bhushan said, "This is a sensible step given the circumstances. Virtual hearings have proven effective during the pandemic and can be a viable option now." However, some lawyers expressed concerns about technical glitches and the need for robust internet connectivity in courtrooms.
No Mandatory Directive
The court clarified that it would not impose a blanket order for virtual hearings, respecting the autonomy of lawyers and the nature of cases. It stated that physical hearings would continue as usual for matters requiring in-person arguments. The registry has been asked to facilitate seamless virtual proceedings for those opting to appear online.
Future Implications
Legal experts believe this could set a precedent for adopting hybrid hearing models in Indian courts, especially during extreme weather or emergencies. The Supreme Court has already been conducting a mix of physical and virtual hearings since the COVID-19 pandemic, and this advisory reinforces the flexibility of the system.
As the heatwave persists, the court's advisory serves as a timely reminder to prioritize health while ensuring justice delivery remains uninterrupted.
