New York Knicks guard Josh Hart has become the latest professional athlete to experience a devastating theft after luxury items worth approximately $185,000 disappeared from his Manhattan hotel room. The incident occurred at The Dominick Hotel in the upscale SoHo district, raising serious questions about security at high-end establishments frequented by celebrities.
The Midday Hotel Robbery
The robbery took place on September 5, 2025, turning what should have been a routine offseason stay into a security nightmare. According to police reports, Hart checked into the luxury hotel and dropped off his duffle bag containing a valuable watch case around 12:30 p.m. When he returned just one hour later, the bag had vanished without a trace.
Investigators confirmed the stolen items included three luxury watches and a bracelet with a combined value of $185,000. While specific brands haven't been officially disclosed, the collection likely included high-end timepieces from manufacturers like Rolex or Audemars Piguet, given Hart's known passion for luxury accessories.
Investigation Challenges and Security Concerns
As of late November, the NYPD investigation continues with no arrests or suspects named. Police haven't determined whether the theft was an inside job by hotel staff, the work of other guests, or executed by professional thieves familiar with the hotel's security protocols.
The brazen nature of the midday heist has sparked widespread concern, particularly because The Dominick Hotel is known for hosting celebrity clientele and maintaining tight security measures. The case highlights a growing pattern of athletes being targeted for their valuable possessions while traveling.
Hart, who recently signed an $81 million contract with the Knicks, maintains a residence in Westchester but was staying downtown to attend a New York City event scheduled for September 6.
Athlete Security and Career Context
Josh Hart has established himself as one of the New York Knicks' most reliable players, breaking the franchise record for single-season triple-doubles last season. Under new head coach Mike Brown, he continues to deliver strong performances, averaging 10.4 points and 7.1 rebounds per game.
Off the court, Hart shares the passion for high-end fashion and watches common among NBA stars. This incident mirrors similar thefts involving other prominent players including Shai Gilgeous-Alexander and Karl-Anthony Towns, reigniting debates about whether professional athletes should travel with expensive jewelry.
The Villanova University alumnus remains part of the beloved 2016 NCAA championship team that included current Knicks teammates Jalen Brunson and Mikal Bridges, adding to the public interest in his personal security and wellbeing.
As the investigation continues without significant leads, the sports world watches to see if Hart's stolen property will be recovered, similar to how watches belonging to actor Keanu Reeves were eventually found through federal investigations. Despite the substantial financial loss, those familiar with Hart's resilient playing style expect him to maintain focus as the Knicks pursue NBA Cup success against rivals like the Milwaukee Bucks.
