In a notable intervention from across the Atlantic, acclaimed American singer and vocal supporter of India Mary Millben has publicly expressed her strong backing for Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Her comments come as a direct rebuttal to recent critical remarks about India made by former US President Donald Trump, which she labelled as "ill-advised."
A Vocal Defence of Strategic Partnership
Mary Millben, known for her renditions of both the American and Indian national anthems, took to social media platform X (formerly Twitter) to articulate her position. She emphasised the critical importance of the US-India relationship, describing it as the "most consequential partnership" of the 21st century for America. Millben stressed that this strategic alliance is vital not just for regional stability in Asia but for global security and economic prosperity as a whole.
Her statement served as a clear correction to the narrative. Millben explicitly stated that any commentary suggesting India is not a friend or ally to the United States is simply incorrect and misinformed. She pointed to the deep and growing ties between the world's two largest democracies, spanning defence, technology, and trade.
Context: Trump's Controversial Comments
The singer's defence was prompted by remarks from Donald Trump, the presumptive Republican nominee for the upcoming US Presidential election. During a recent campaign speech, Trump accused India of being indebted to the United States and claimed the country was no longer a reliable ally. He specifically referenced India's increased purchases of Russian oil following the Ukraine conflict, framing it as a betrayal.
These comments sparked immediate concern and debate within diplomatic and political circles, given India's pivotal role in US foreign policy. Millben's intervention is significant as she is a well-known figure within conservative American circles and has previously performed at events for the Republican Hindu Coalition.
Millben's Personal Advocacy for India
Mary Millben is no stranger to advocating for stronger Indo-US relations. She has consistently used her platform to highlight India's democratic values and its leadership under PM Modi. In her recent post, she praised Modi's governance, aligning herself with the many American leaders and citizens who, in her words, "respect and support" the Indian Prime Minister.
Her support extends beyond mere words; Millben has a history of celebrating Indian culture publicly. She famously sang the Indian national anthem, 'Jana Gana Mana,' in Hindi ahead of PM Modi's 2019 visit to the US. She repeated this gesture before his state visit in June 2023, performing the anthem at a Capitol Hill reception. Furthermore, she has also performed 'Vande Mataram,' solidifying her connection with Indian audiences.
Implications for Diaspora and Diplomacy
This public disagreement highlights the nuanced perspectives within the American political landscape regarding India. While Trump's comments reflect a transactional view of foreign policy, Millben represents a strand of opinion that values the long-term strategic and democratic alignment between the two nations.
The episode is particularly relevant for the influential Indian-American diaspora and the pro-India constituency in Washington. It underscores that support for India is bipartisan, even if approaches differ. Millben's stance reinforces the message that the US-India partnership is broader than any single political figure or momentary disagreement.
As the United States moves towards its November elections, the tone and substance of its policy towards India will remain under scrutiny. Voices like Mary Millben's serve as a reminder of the partnership's deep-rooted supporters who advocate for its continued strengthening, irrespective of the political winds in Washington.
