In a significant move, the prominent Jewish civil rights organisation StopAntisemitism has designated conservative podcaster and commentator Tucker Carlson as its 'Antisemite of the Year'. The group accuses Carlson of playing a pivotal role in mainstreaming anti-Jewish ideas and conspiracy theories through his widely followed platform.
Why Carlson Was Given the Controversial Title
According to StopAntisemitism, Carlson's consistent rhetoric has helped normalise antisemitic tropes. The organisation points to his repeated questioning of America's alliance with Israel, labelling Christian Zionism a 'brain virus'. Furthermore, he has been accused of stating that Israel intentionally murders children in Gaza.
The group highlighted a specific instance where Carlson's imagery during a eulogy for Charlie Kirk reportedly echoed age-old stereotypes about clandestine Jewish power. StopAntisemitism argues that Carlson has provided substantial platforms to individuals who promote dangerous conspiracy theories, including suggestions of hidden Israeli influence within the U.S. government. This combination, the organisation states, has made his impact particularly severe.
Controversial Interviews and Endorsements
A major point of contention cited was Carlson's October interview with Nick Fuentes, a known white nationalist and Holocaust denier. The lengthy conversation drew immediate and heavy criticism. During the interview, Fuentes targeted Jewish communities, women, and the American political system, framing "organized Jewry in America" as a threat to national unity and alleging dual loyalty among Jewish Americans.
In another controversial move, Carlson lavishly praised writer Darryl Cooper, whom he introduced in a 2024 interview as "the most important popular historian in the United States." He endorsed Cooper's work as "forbidden history," granting him credibility before millions of viewers. StopAntisemitism notes that Carlson has repeatedly promoted the 'Great Replacement' theory and gave Cooper a platform despite severe criticism from academics and the White House.
Cooper is a revisionist who argues the Holocaust was not premeditated but resulted from Nazi "unpreparedness" and logistical failures. He also portrays Winston Churchill as World War II's "chief villain" and has suggested some Nazi killings were done for "humane" reasons. Carlson invited Cooper back for another discussion in July 2025.
Carlson's Response and the Broader Impact
Tucker Carlson has firmly denied all allegations from StopAntisemitism. He maintains that he condemns antisemitism and believes that criticism of any government, including Israel's, should not be conflated with hate speech.
However, the organisation stands by its decision, asserting that Carlson's actions have crossed a line from political commentary into the dangerous territory of legitimising hate. This designation places Carlson alongside other figures accused of fuelling religious and ethnic hatred, sparking a wider debate on the limits of free speech and the responsibility of influential media personalities.
