A judge ruled Friday that Blake Lively can recover some legal costs from fellow actor and director Justin Baldoni, but not punitive damages and other relief she sought after settling her legal claims over their 2024 film "It Ends With Us."
Judge Orders Justin Baldoni to Pay Blake Lively's Legal Fees
Judge Lewis J. Liman said in a written decision that Lively can recover legal fees and costs related to her defense against a countersuit Baldoni brought after she sued him in December 2024. In his ruling, Liman cited a California law designed to protect survivors of sexual harassment and discrimination from retaliatory lawsuits meant to intimidate and silence victims.
The judge explained that the law requires the plaintiff to pay the defendant's legal fees and costs if a defamation claim made in response to a lawsuit is dismissed, even if the facts have not been fully developed through evidence gathering. An exception would apply if Baldoni and his production company, Wayfarer Studios LLC, could prove malice fueled Lively's claims, but they produced no evidence of that.
Judge Rejects Blake Lively's Claims for Punitive Damages
The judge rejected her claims to triple any damages and pursue punitive damages under the California law, stating they did not fall within "carefully crafted federal procedural rules designed to protect the rights of the parties." Lively and Baldoni settled the bulk of their dispute last month just as a trial was set to begin on Lively's retaliation claims. She received no money from the deal but was permitted to pursue legal fees.
Victory for Both Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni
In their statements, both sides cast Liman's ruling as a victory. Lively's lawyers Michael Gottlieb and Esra Hudson said the award of legal fees "makes it clear that Ms. Lively brought her claims in good faith, that there was no evidence she acted with malice, and that she is the prevailing defendant."
Bryan Freedman, Baldoni's lawyer, said Lively failed to get her demands for USD 300 million in fees and damages, with 10 of her 13 claims tossed out before the settlement, and then "pivoted to exploit a California law" to get damages. "Once again, she failed," he said, noting she was entitled only to limited attorney fees for a single claim in a portion of the litigation that existed for a few months.
Freedman added that his clients were "threatened by one of the most famous movie stars, who tried to rip away their life's work and pristine reputations." He stated: "Throughout this process, innocent people had their reputations unfairly tarnished. There was no sexual harassment. There was no retaliation. There was no smear campaign. The court recognized it, the record reflects it, and we have maintained it from the very beginning."
About Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni's Legal Battle
Lively accused Baldoni of sexual harassment and retaliation, along with his production company, in late 2024. She claimed the actor engineered an effort to damage her public reputation and credibility. Baldoni, who directed the dark romantic drama and starred in it with Lively, denied harassing her or orchestrating a smear campaign. He contended that Lively fabricated complaints about his behavior to seize creative control of the movie. He countersued, accusing Lively and her husband, "Deadpool" actor Ryan Reynolds, of defamation and extortion.
Liman threw out Baldoni's countersuit last year and dismissed Lively's sexual harassment claims weeks ago, ruling she could not bring them because she was an independent contractor rather than an employee on the movie set.
"It Ends With Us," an adaptation of Colleen Hoover's bestselling 2016 novel about a relationship devolving into domestic violence, was released in August 2024 and exceeded box office expectations.
Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni's Filmography
Lively appeared in the 2005 film "The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants" and the TV series "Gossip Girl" from 2007 to 2012 before starring in films including "The Town" and "The Shallows." Baldoni starred in the TV comedy "Jane the Virgin," directed the 2019 film "Five Feet Apart," and wrote "Man Enough," a book challenging traditional notions of masculinity.
