What was meant to be a private, joyous moment for New York Yankees infielder Jazz Chisholm Jr. quickly spiraled into a public spectacle, forcing the athlete to confront baseless online rumors about his fiancée. Chisholm's romantic Christmas proposal under the Northern Lights was overshadowed by unfounded claims on social media, leading to a direct and forceful response from the baseball star.
A Fairytale Proposal Under the Northern Lights
On December 25, 2025, while on a snowy vacation in Finland, Jazz Chisholm Jr. proposed to his girlfriend, Ahnalys Santiago. The memorable moment occurred under the mesmerizing Aurora Borealis, creating a perfect backdrop for the engagement. Santiago, completely surprised by the gesture, later revealed that Chisholm had cleverly tricked her into believing nothing special was planned for the day.
The news went public when Santiago shared photos of her stunning oval-cut diamond ring on Instagram, enthusiastically declaring, “I’m not Da Gurl anymore yallllll I’m DA WIFEEEEEEEE.” Images of Chisholm kneeling in the snow, notably wearing Louis Vuitton scarves, spread rapidly across the internet. Fans of the Yankees, celebrating Chisholm's impressive 30-home run, 30-steal season, flooded social media with congratulations, with some even humorously suggesting the team extend his contract, which runs through 2026.
How Social Media Rumors Spiraled Out of Control
Before the engagement announcement, the couple had posted lighthearted Christmas Eve content featuring Grinch-themed outfits and spa clips. However, after the proposal went viral, the tone on platforms like X (formerly Twitter) and Reddit turned sour. Some users began digging into Santiago's online history, leading to false allegations that she operated an OnlyFans account and labeling her a “model” in a derogatory context.
The rumors escalated quickly, with some posts mocking Chisholm with comments like, “You will be broke in 5 years.” While rival fans amplified the noise, several users defended the couple, pointing out the racist and misogynistic undertones in the criticism targeting Santiago.
Chisholm's Blunt and Sarcastic Clapback
Instead of letting the rumors fester, Jazz Chisholm Jr. chose to address them head-on. He actively entered the conversation on X, leaving no room for ambiguity. In a clear and definitive statement, he replied, “My fiancé has never done OnlyFans.”
When the speculation persisted despite his denial, Chisholm responded with biting sarcasm. He fired back at trolls, writing, “But maybe your mom did check on her right quick.” He further accused certain accounts of “scamming” people with fake profiles and pushed back against those criticizing his choice of partner.
Ahnalys Santiago also joined the fray in her own style, posting a video where she humorously asserted that she “runs the house.” As the online notifications overwhelmed his phone, Chisholm even joked that his fiancée was “banning” him from social media due to the constant alert barrage.
Fan Support and a Louder-Than-Expected Offseason
The incident sparked a broader discussion among sports fans. Many Yankees supporters rallied around Chisholm and Santiago, choosing to focus on celebrating their engagement rather than the malicious gossip. The episode also led to debates about why the partners of professional athletes are frequently subjected to such intense and unfair online scrutiny, drawing parallels to similar stories across various sports.
For Jazz Chisholm Jr., who ended the season reflecting on playoff lessons, this has been an unexpectedly loud start to his offseason. The entire situation highlights how quickly a personal milestone can be hijacked by the public sphere and demonstrates the firm stance the Yankees star is willing to take to defend his future wife's reputation.
