The Kansas City Chiefs face an unusual offseason challenge. For the first time in the Patrick Mahomes era, quarterback stability is in question. Mahomes suffered a torn ACL, leaving the team without a clear return date. While optimism persists, there is a real chance he might miss the opening weeks of the 2026 NFL season.
Chiefs Adopt Pragmatic Approach
This uncertainty forces Kansas City to think practically about short-term options. The priority is not flashy roster moves or long-term potential. Instead, the focus is on maintaining offensive structure early in the season. The organization wants to give Mahomes ample time for full recovery.
The current discussion revolves around finding a quarterback who can execute steadily. This player must not disrupt the team's broader identity. The Chiefs need someone who can keep the offense functional during Mahomes' absence.
Why Gardner Minshew Emerges as a Logical Choice
NFL insider Nick Shook believes the simplest solution might be the most effective. He points to Gardner Minshew as a logical short-term answer for Kansas City. Minshew served as Patrick Mahomes' primary backup during the 2025 season.
He suffered a late-year knee injury, but it was not ACL-related. This injury is expected to heal ahead of Mahomes' recovery timeline. That difference alone positions Minshew to be available earlier. The Chiefs might need coverage at the start of 2026.
"Minshew suffered a season-ending knee injury of his own, but it wasn't an ACL tear," Shook wrote. "He should be ready to play sooner than Mahomes, bringing veteran backup experience to a Kansas City team that suddenly needs it more than ever."
Familiarity with Andy Reid's System Adds Value
Beyond health considerations, Minshew's familiarity with Andy Reid's system carries significant weight. He understands the playbook thoroughly. He knows the weekly preparation demands and locker room expectations.
This familiarity reduces the adjustment period that often comes with outside additions. For a team coming off a surprising 6–11 season, minimizing early disruption becomes a top priority.
Proven Ability to Manage Games Under Pressure
Shook also highlighted Minshew's performance in 2023. He stepped in for Anthony Richardson in Indianapolis and kept the Colts in postseason contention. That stretch demonstrated his ability to manage games effectively.
He showed he can protect the football and keep an offense operational under pressure. These traits align perfectly with what Kansas City would require during Mahomes' absence.
Consistency Over Spectacle
Minshew's personality and play style sometimes attract attention. However, the value here is consistency rather than spectacle. If Mahomes misses playing time, the goal is not to match elite production.
The objective is to maintain competitive functionality until Mahomes returns. Viewed through this lens, re-signing Minshew represents a practical decision. It is grounded in stability and realistic expectations for the team's immediate future.
