Brokerage Firms Issue Key Ratings on Major Indian Stocks
Emkay Global Financial Services has initiated its coverage of Avenue Supermart, the operator of D-Mart retail stores, with a sell rating and a target price set at Rs 3,700 per share. Analysts at the firm expressed concerns that the stock is currently trading at approximately 70 times its forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio, which they argue prices in an idealized future business performance rather than reflecting the company's present reality.
Competitive Pressures and Market Coverage
According to the report, quick commerce platforms have significantly narrowed their pricing gap with D-Mart, now being only 4-13% more expensive on a typical monthly shopping basket when bank discounts are factored in. This development erodes one of D-Mart's traditional competitive advantages. Furthermore, the company currently covers only about 50% of India's total addressable retail market (TAM), indicating substantial room for expansion but also highlighting current limitations.
Emkay analysts noted that D-Mart's P/E-to-growth (PEG) ratio stands at 4.2x, compared to 2.6x for competitors like Trent and Titan, suggesting the market is paying for perfection in a business that requires structural reforms. The brokerage's bear case scenario projects a much lower target price of Rs 2,200 for the stock.
Morgan Stanley's Cautious Optimism on UPL
In a separate development, Morgan Stanley has resumed its coverage of agrochemical giant UPL with an equal weight rating and a target price of Rs 658. Analysts view UPL as a strategic play on the anticipated revival in global crop chemical volumes, noting the company has delivered two consecutive years of solid volume growth.
While generally constructive about improving agricultural chemical cycles, Morgan Stanley remains cautious due to near-term uncertainties. These include supply chain dislocations, challenges in feedstock sourcing, and potential demand risks. The report highlights that UPL has outperformed its global listed peers by delivering approximately 2 to 2.5 times higher volume growth over the past eight quarters.
Analysts believe UPL's extensive global footprint positions it well to leverage the expected repair cycle in the industry. They project the company can deliver volume growth at or above the industry average of 3-6% while gaining market share through fiscal years 2027-2028.
HSBC Initiates Buy Rating for Acme Solar
HSBC has initiated coverage of Acme Solar with a buy rating and a target price of Rs 350. The brokerage describes Acme as one of India's fastest-growing, vertically-integrated, independent power producers in the renewable energy sector.
The company's approximately 6GW of contracted capacity provides strong long-term earnings visibility. Additionally, its investments in firm and dispatchable renewable energy (FDRE) projects and battery energy storage systems (BESS) are expected to enhance returns significantly.
HSBC forecasts that Acme Solar will achieve an impressive earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA) compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) of 72% during the fiscal years 2026 through 2028.
Additional Brokerage Actions
ICICI Securities has initiated coverage of Sumitomo Chemicals with a buy rating and a target price of Rs 515. Analysts praised the company's unique positioning with solid credentials and reasonable valuation that offers material upside potential. They highlighted its symbiotic dominance combining global innovation with local market expertise, creating what they describe as an unparalleled competitive moat. Aggressive capital expenditure plans and new product launches are expected to support sustained growth momentum, with Indian agriculture demand projected to remain robust for the next 12-18 months.
Goldman Sachs maintains a buy rating on Eternal with a target price of Rs 350. Analysts addressed concerns about Blinkit's total addressable market (TAM), suggesting these worries may be overstated from a value perspective. They noted that the industry's monthly transaction user (MTU) penetration has exceeded 50% of the underlying TAM and could approach maturity levels within 1-2 years.
Regarding competition, Goldman Sachs expects Blinkit to continue gaining market share against Swiggy, though they acknowledged that growth may have been adversely impacted recently due to elevated competition from both new entrants and existing players. However, they contested the notion that this competition would prevent margin expansion for Blinkit, pointing to evidence from the December 2025 quarter and expressing confidence that sufficient operational levers exist to offset potential headwinds.
Disclaimer: Recommendations and views on the stock market, other asset classes or personal finance management tips given by experts are their own. These opinions do not represent the views of The Times of India.
