Kolkata: Employees at the Indian Statistical Institute (ISI), Kolkata, expressed confusion on Thursday regarding an advisory issued by the authorities, as no major incident on campus had threatened communal harmony or national integrity. The advisory, released a day earlier, urged staff members to refrain from any activity or public comment that could harm these values.
Background of the Advisory
The institute has recently witnessed protests against the draft ISI Bill, which many believe could compromise its autonomy. Additionally, a faculty member was arrested for a social media post accusing the Election Commission of bias. However, faculty members argue that neither event amounted to a threat to communal harmony or national integrity. They contend that the advisory itself may pose a risk to dissenting voices within the institute.
Details of the Advisory
The advisory on public statements and professional conduct stated: “In view of the recent developments and various communications being received by the institute, highlighting the critical need to safeguard our institutional reputation, all scientific and non-scientific employees are advised to maintain the highest standards of professional and personal conduct, strictly refrain from participating in any activity or making any public commentary that could be detrimental to communal harmony or national integrity, and protect and enhance the name and reputation of the ISI at all times.”
Reactions from Faculty and Staff
A source suggested that the advisory was likely issued by the director following a communication from higher authorities. A senior professor described it as an indication of harder times ahead. Another professor remarked, “Students, teachers, and staff have protested the Bill that plans to snatch ISI Kolkata’s autonomy and shift the headquarters. The advisory is a way to intimidate employees and throttle dissent.” A third professor expressed apprehension about potential restrictions on research topics critical of the government.
Alumnus Perspective
Abhinandan Sinha, an ISI Kolkata alumnus, stated, “Data-based policy research institutes are vital for evidence-based feedback from independent research. Unnecessary bureaucratic control over extra-academic matters derails primary objectives and spoils the free-spirited environment needed for independent research. Academic freedom cannot be de-linked from social freedom.” He added that freedom of speech and participation in social causes are fundamental rights, and employers are not positioned to judge an individual’s social opinions unless they directly pertain to academic activities. Controversies in such realms should be left to law enforcement.
Stay updated with the latest Kolkata news. Download the TOI App.
